close popup
Skip to main content
Skip to footer

The NewQuill+

Become a member to receive free shipping—no minimum. Tell Me More

Close
Limited time offer

Free Shipping. No Minimum.

Code: FREESHIP

Offer good through 8/15/22.

Rewards & Incentives  (477 Products)
Sort By:
Super Duper® Prize Bucket of Motivational Toys & Prizes, 150 Pieces per Bucket

Super Duper® Prize Bucket of Motivational Toys & Prizes, 150 Pieces per Bucket

Teaching aids grade/age: Ages 3 years and up
Excellent motivational and reinforcement toys
Assortments may include hopping frogs, bracelets, clappers, whistles, spinning tops, rings and more
$34.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-308270SUP
Model # SD609
Trend Stinky Stickers Praise Words Jumbo Variety Pack, Assorted Scented Stickers, 432 Stickers/Pk

Trend Stinky Stickers Praise Words Jumbo Variety Pack, Assorted Scented Stickers, 432 Stickers/Pk

Inspirational words printd on scented stickers
1 1/4" diameter
Each large, round sticker has a burst of fragrance to be scratched and sniffed
$15.59 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-TEPT6490
Model # T6490
Sticker Valu-Pak, Assorted Color Foil Stars, 686/Pk

Sticker Valu-Pak, Assorted Color Foil Stars, 686/Pk

Motivates and rewards students
Perfect for color-coding
Comes in gold, green, blue, red and silver
$4.89 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-TCR6644
Model # TEE6644
Moon Products Try Rex® Jumbo Pencil With Eraser, Dozen (JRMB21T)

Moon Products Try Rex® Jumbo Pencil With Eraser, Dozen (JRMB21T)

Large soft graphite core for good black marks
Jumbo size for beginners
Dozen per pack, 36 total
$24.29 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-872692
Model # JRMB21T
Teacher Created Resources Plastic Treasure Chest (TCR8759)

Teacher Created Resources Plastic Treasure Chest (TCR8759)

Great for pirate-themed parties, as a gift or storage box, or for a rewards chest in your classroom
Each chest has an oil-rubbed bronze look with an easy-open lid attached by built-in hinges
Suggested age range: 5+ years
$31.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24439148
Model # TCR8759
Teacher Created Resources® Watercolor Words to Inspire Planner Stickers, Pack of 120 (TCR8193)

Teacher Created Resources® Watercolor Words to Inspire Planner Stickers, Pack of 120 (TCR8193)

Give your lesson planner the royal treatment with these stunning planner stickers
Watercolor Sticker Design
Great for all ages
$4.39 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24322884
Model # TCR8193
Teacher Created Resources Colorful Circles Mini Stickers, 3/8 Diameter, 1144/PacK, 6 PacK/Bundle (T

Teacher Created Resources Colorful Circles Mini Stickers, 3/8" Diameter, 1144/PacK, 6 PacK/Bundle (TCR4743)

Get a great deal on super-sized valu-paks of stickers
Each sticker is 3/8" in diameter
1144 stickers per pack
$30.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-879246
Model # TCR4743
Smilemakers® Round Tooth Holder

Smilemakers® Round Tooth Holder

WARNING: CHOKING HAZARD – Small parts. Not for children under 3 yrs.
$12.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-58428
Model # TOTH
Carson-Dellosa Celebrate Learning Motivational Stickers, 72/Pack (168254)

Carson-Dellosa Celebrate Learning Motivational Stickers, 72/Pack (168254)

Assorted shapes and colors of these stickers are perfect for decorating folders, cubbies, bins, schoolwork, and more
Great for craft projects such as posters, scrapbooks, calendars, and invitations
A must-have for any teacher’s desk or prize box
$2.59 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24356786
Model # 168254
S&S® All Occasion Value Greeting Card, 120/Pack

S&S® All Occasion Value Greeting Card, 120/Pack

Size: 4" X 6"
Assorted
Teaching resource topic: Party and novelty
$32.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-12693SSW
Model # SL2790
Carson-Dellosa Colorful Owls Stickers, Assorted, 72/Pack (168145)

Carson-Dellosa Colorful Owls Stickers, Assorted, 72/Pack (168145)

Stickers are an essential addition to any teacher's desk or treasure chest
Animal themed stickers are decorated with colorful owls and are available in assorted colors
72 stickers per pack
$2.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-1560555
Model # 168145
Super Duper® Extra Tub of Bingo Chips, 225/Pack (BGC225)

Super Duper® Extra Tub of Bingo Chips, 225/Pack (BGC225)

Size: Tub is 4 5/8" diameter
Approximately 225 hard, plastic chips in assorted colors
Chips are 3/4" diameter
$5.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-307806SUP
Model # BGC225
Teacher Created Resources Classroom Reward Treasure Chest (TCR5048)

Teacher Created Resources Classroom Reward Treasure Chest (TCR5048)

Type of incentive: Classroom Rewards
Item Color: Brown
Suggested grades: Pre-K+
$14.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV63432
Model # TCR5048
Schoolgirl Style Stars Birthday Crowns, 30 Crowns/Pack (101085)

Schoolgirl Style Stars Birthday Crowns, 30 Crowns/Pack (101085)

Celebratory birthday crowns are perfect to use for each student's birthday.
Add fun and excitement to special occasions to make them extraordinary.
Give your students the royal treatment for their special days.
$14.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24355995
Model # 101085
Carson-Dellosa Dazzle Incentive Charts & Seals, Assorted Colors, 440/Pack (2143)

Carson-Dellosa Dazzle Incentive Charts & Seals, Assorted Colors, 440/Pack (2143)

Chart seals perfect for any incentive chart or job chart
Smiley faces chart seals featuring sparkling designs, available in a wide variety of colors
Each sticker measures 0.38"Dia.
$2.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-1561499
Model # 2143
Carson-Dellosa Celebrate Learning Stickers, Multi Colors, 72/Pack (168254)

Carson-Dellosa Celebrate Learning Stickers, Multi Colors, 72/Pack (168254)

Motivational reward stickers are a small, fun way to brighten a student's day
Stickers feature positive messages such as: "Star Student", "I am a Problem Solver", "I make Good Choices", etc.
Pack includes six sheets of 12 colorful die-cut stickers for a total of 72 stickers
$2.49 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24359618
Model # 168254HC
Eureka® Stickers, Numbers 1 - 20 (EU-655990)

Eureka® Stickers, Numbers 1 - 20 (EU-655990)

Design: Numbers 1 - 20
Size: 1" x 1"
Fun and decorative
$31.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-157550
Model # EU655990
Trend Enterprises Congratulations Award Certificates, Assorted Colors, 8 1/2H x 11W, 30/Pk

Trend Enterprises "Congratulations" Award Certificates, Assorted Colors, 8 1/2"H x 11"W, 30/Pk

Each certificate measures 8 1/2"H x 11"W
No slots
Featuring inspiring quotes and contemporary art work
$11.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-578632
Model # T2959
Trend Enterprises© Certificate of Award Certificates, Assorted Colors, 8 1/2H x 11W, 30/Pk

Trend Enterprises© "Certificate of Award" Certificates, Assorted Colors, 8 1/2"H x 11"W, 30/Pk

Each certificate measures 8 1/2"H x 11"W
No slots
Featuring inspiring quotes and contemporary art work
$6.49 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-579544
Model # T2951
Moon Products Red/Blue Swirl Ink Pen, 12/Pack (JRMP80)

Moon Products Red/Blue Swirl Ink Pen, 12/Pack (JRMP80)

Ink color: Red/Blue
Theme/design: Swirl
2 colors in 1 pen
$24.49 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-873830
Model # JRMP80
SmileMakers® Kryptonite Balls

SmileMakers® Kryptonite Balls

Balls look like meteors and bounce high
Assorted colors
Size: 1-1/2" diameter
$31.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-58401
Model # CRYP
SmileMakers® Brush, Floss, Smile Balloons; 72 PCS

SmileMakers® Brush, Floss, Smile Balloons; 72 PCS

Size: 9" inflated
Colorful balloons are a great treat!
Size: 9 inches inflated
$30.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-BAL25SMI
Model # BAL25
Sandy Lion Incentive Chart Mini Sticker Variety Pack, 3200 ct. (SLSTEPGCC)

Sandy Lion Incentive Chart Mini Sticker Variety Pack, 3200 ct. (SLSTEPGCC)

Type of incentive: Reward Stickers
Theme/design: Bugs, butterflies, dinosaurs, weather/stars
Suggested grades: PreK - 5
$11.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV52716
Model # SLSTEPGCC
superSpots® Sticker Variety Pack, Neon Smiles, 2,500 per Pack

superSpots® Sticker Variety Pack, Neon Smiles, 2,500 per Pack

Child-pleasing, positive messages and appealing designs
Use for student rewards and on homework folders
Just the right size for Incentive Charts and Incentive Pads
$7.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-TEPT1942
Model # T1942M
Stinky Stickers® Scratch-and-Sniff Variety Pack, Fun & Fancy, 432/Pk

Stinky Stickers® Scratch-and-Sniff Variety Pack, Fun & Fancy, 432/Pk

432 stickers per pack
Acid-free, nontoxic and safe for use on photos
Scratch-and-sniff stickers are ideal motivators and rewards
$14.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-TEPT6491
Model # T6491
TREND® Animal Pals Stinky Stickers® Variety Pack, 385 Count (T-83915)

TREND® Animal Pals Stinky Stickers® Variety Pack, 385 Count (T-83915)

Reward your students with stickers! Cute animals with phrases of encouragement.
Colorful, cute animals
Great for all ages
$16.59 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24322862
Model # T-83915
Creative Teaching Press Bible Verses in Chalk Rejoice Inspire U Poster 3-Pack  (CTP2274)

Creative Teaching Press Bible Verses in Chalk Rejoice Inspire U Poster 3-Pack (CTP2274)

Classroom Inspirational Posters
Bible Verses
Posters measure 13 3/8" x 19"
$14.79 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV2659017
Model # CTP2274
Trend Stinky Stickers, Assorted Colors, 480/Pack (T-089)

Trend Stinky Stickers, Assorted Colors, 480/Pack (T-089)

Stinky Stickers are fun to collect or use to motivate and reward
Come in assorted colors with 15 different scents
48 assorted designs
$15.79 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-TEPT089
Model # T089M
Carson-Dellosa Dazzle Incentive Charts & Seals, Assorted Colors, 440/Pack (2141)

Carson-Dellosa Dazzle Incentive Charts & Seals, Assorted Colors, 440/Pack (2141)

Chart seals perfect for any incentive chart or job chart
Hearts chart seals featuring sparkling designs, available in a wide variety of colors
Each sticker measures 0.38"Dia.
$2.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-1561500
Model # 2141
S&S® Clear Cello Shrink Wrap Rolls, 3/Pack

S&S® Clear Cello Shrink Wrap Rolls, 3/Pack

Size: 60" X 108"
Clear
Teaching resource topic: Party and novelty
$24.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-15214SSW
Model # 99816
Eureka Stars & Smiles SPARKLE Sticker Book, 268 ct. (EU-609400)

Eureka Stars & Smiles SPARKLE Sticker Book, 268 ct. (EU-609400)

Type of incentive: Stickers
Color(s): multi
Suggested grades: Pre-K-12
$7.69 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV43030
Model # EU609400
Carson-Dellosa Colorful Owls Stickers, Assorted Colors, 216/Pack (168052)

Carson-Dellosa Colorful Owls Stickers, Assorted Colors, 216/Pack (168052)

Incentives are designed as prize pack stickers
Stickers are decorated with colorful owls and available in different colors and shapes
Each sticker measures approximately 1"H x 1"W
$1.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-864237
Model # CARSON-DELLOSA
Eureka Peanuts Sticker Book, 410 ct. (EU-609600)

Eureka Peanuts Sticker Book, 410 ct. (EU-609600)

Type of incentive: Stickers
Color(s): multi
Suggested grades: Pre-K-12
$10.59 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV157648
Model # EU609600
New
Teacher Created Resources® Gold Stars Foil Stickers, Gold, 294 Per Pack, 12 Packs (TCR1276-12)
$35.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24497445
Model # TCR1276-12
Trend Enterprises Variety Pack Sparkle Stickers, School Days, 648/Pack (T-63909)

Trend Enterprises Variety Pack Sparkle Stickers, School Days, 648/Pack (T-63909)

Sparkle Stickers® add pizzazz to nametags, reports, invitations, scrapbooks, assignments, and more
Fun assortment in each jumbo pack. Great for party favors, storytelling, and awards, too!
Acid-free, nontoxic, and photo-safe.
$17.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24417510
Model # T-63909
Endless Possibilities Boinks! Teacher Pack, 28 ct. (EPBBT28)

Endless Possibilities Boinks! Teacher Pack, 28 ct. (EPBBT28)

Boinks teacher pack is well suited for play or therapy
Offers a safe, durable, fun, fidget and stress relieving toys perfect for ultimate entertainment
Suitable for ages 3 - 14 years and grades kindergarten - 12th
$25.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV1610138
Model # EPBBT28
Carson-Dellosa Positive Words Stickers, Multi Colors, 84/Pack (168016)

Carson-Dellosa Positive Words Stickers, Multi Colors, 84/Pack (168016)

Incentives are designed as shape stickers
Stickers feature positive words and are available in different colors and shapes
The pack includes 84 stickers
$2.49 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-2436890
Model # 168016
Carson-Dellosa Nature Explorers Awards & Certificates, 49 Cut-Outs Per Pack (120237)

Carson-Dellosa Nature Explorers Awards & Certificates, 49 Cut-Outs Per Pack (120237)

Perfect incentives to encourage and reinforce good choices
Great for building student confidence and reinforcing skills
Durable and reusable
$4.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24402235
Model # 120237
Teacher Created Resources® Watercolor Star Mini Stickers, Pack of 378 (TCR8897)

Teacher Created Resources® Watercolor Star Mini Stickers, Pack of 378 (TCR8897)

Give your lesson planner the royal treatment with these stunning planner stickers
Watercolor themed
Suggested for ages 10 + years
$4.59 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24323022
Model # TCR8897
Carson-Dellosa Positive Words Stickers, Multi Colors, 120/Pack (0625)

Carson-Dellosa Positive Words Stickers, Multi Colors, 120/Pack (0625)

Positive words stickers are a small, fun way to brighten a student's day
Multicolor stickers feature a variety of motivational words perfect for reward or recognition
Each sticker measures 1"H x 1"W
$2.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-1561501
Model # 0625
New
Teacher Created Resources® Mini Colorful Circles Valu-Pak Stickers, Assorted, 1144 Per Pack, 6 Packs
$30.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24497497
Model # TCR4743-6
Eureka® Stickers, Peanuts Characters (EU-655111)

Eureka® Stickers, Peanuts Characters (EU-655111)

Size: 1 5/16"(L) x 1 3/4"(W)
Reward good work and excellent behavior or boost a student's self-esteem with colorful giant stickers
Students love stickers
$32.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-932662
Model # EU-655111
Trend Stinky Stickers, Assorted Colors, 648/Pack (T-83905)

Trend Stinky Stickers, Assorted Colors, 648/Pack (T-83905)

Stinky Stickers are fun to collect or use to motivate and reward
Come in six assorted colors: red, yellow, purple, orange, green, and blue with four different scents
Designs include colorful smiles and star smiles
$17.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-TEPT83905
Model # T83905
Eureka Presto-Stick 3/4 Foil Star Stickers, Gold, 175 ct. (EU-82424)

Eureka Presto-Stick 3/4" Foil Star Stickers, Gold, 175 ct. (EU-82424)

Type of incentive: Stickers - Label
Color(s): gold
Suggested grades: Pre-K-12
$6.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV51193
Model # EU-82424Q
Carson-Dellosa Celebrate Learning Mini Incentive Charts, 660 Pieces Per Pack (148036)

Carson-Dellosa Celebrate Learning Mini Incentive Charts, 660 Pieces Per Pack (148036)

Track and reward students' progress with mini incentive charts and coordinating chart seals
Each celebration-themed chart has space for a student's name and 20 stickers
Use daily to reinforce routine tasks or to motivate students to work toward completing tasks to reach a goal
$5.39 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24403476
Model # 148036
Trend Enterprises® Award Seals Stickers, Excellence, Gold (T-74003)

Trend Enterprises® Award Seals Stickers, Excellence, Gold (T-74003)

Size: 2"(Dia)
Color: Gold
Theme/design: Certificate, praise/reward/award
$32.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-931648
Model # T-74003
Hygloss 2 x 6 Blank Bookmarks, Assorted, 100/Pack (HYG42610)

Hygloss 2" x 6" Blank Bookmarks, Assorted, 100/Pack (HYG42610)

Age group and grades: Ages 3 - 18 years and up and grades Preschool - 12th
Size: 2" x 6"
Assorted
$24.29 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-975996
Model # HYG42610
Hygloss Bright Assorted Tag Crowns, Pack of 24 (HYG65249)

Hygloss Bright Assorted Tag Crowns, Pack of 24 (HYG65249)

These card stock paper crowns are ready to go for decorating and personalizing for every occasion
Color(s): Red, Green, Yellow, Blue
Theme/design: Fairy tales
$12.79 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV61856
Model # HYG65249
The Pencil Grip Loopeez Fidget, Bundle of 6 (TPG861)

The Pencil Grip Loopeez Fidget, Bundle of 6 (TPG861)

Travel size!
Don't break down into small pieces!
No assembly required!
$26.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-2658857
Model # TPG861
Hayes Publishing Certificate of Achievement, 30 Per Pack, 3 Packs (H-VA508-3)

Hayes Publishing Certificate of Achievement, 30 Per Pack, 3 Packs (H-VA508-3)

Classroom Award
Certificate of Achievment
For 5+ years/Grade K-12
$20.29 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24509631
Model # H-VA508-3
Teacher Created Resources® Mini Stickers, Smiley Stars, 1144/PK, 6 PK/BD

Teacher Created Resources® Mini Stickers, Smiley Stars, 1144/PK, 6 PK/BD

Size: 3/8"(Dia)
Design: Smiley faces, stars
Acid free
$29.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-734302
Model # TCR5141
Eureka Dr. Seuss Scratch Off Rewards, 24 ct. (EU-844209)

Eureka Dr. Seuss Scratch Off Rewards, 24 ct. (EU-844209)

Type of incentive: punch cards
Color(s): multi
Suggested grades: Pre-K-12
$10.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV157544
Model # EU844209
Teacher Created Resources® Mini Stickers, Colorful Paw Prints, 1144/Pack (TCR4742)

Teacher Created Resources® Mini Stickers, Colorful Paw Prints, 1144/Pack (TCR4742)

Size: 3/8"(Dia)
Design: Pet
Co-ordinates with 24" x 18" blank calendar
$27.99 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-848661
Model # TCR4742
Carson-Dellosa Galaxy Awards & Certificates, 36 Cut-Outs Per Pack (120574)

Carson-Dellosa Galaxy Awards & Certificates, 36 Cut-Outs Per Pack (120574)

Perfect incentives to encourage and reinforce good choices
Great for building student confidence and reinforcing skills
Durable and reusable
$5.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24402224
Model # 120574
Barker Creek Friendship Award & Bookmark Set, Soft Gray, 30/Pack (BC434)

Barker Creek Friendship Award & Bookmark Set, Soft Gray, 30/Pack (BC434)

30 Friendship Awards and coordinating bookmarks per package
Students will feel like they are receiving two special recognition gifts in one!
Awards and bookmarks are each double-sided for twice the value!
$11.29 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24356778
Model # BC434
Smilemakers® Toys; 38mm Superballs

Smilemakers® Toys; 38mm Superballs

WARNING: CHOKING HAZARD – This toy is a small ball.  Not for children under 3 yrs.
Fun for everyone! High-bouncing super balls come in assorted designs and colors
Size: 38mm, 1-1/2" in diameter
$36.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-39110
Model # 3BAL
Eureka The Cat in the Hat Pencil Rewards with Toppers, 16 ct. (EU-610101)

Eureka The Cat in the Hat Pencil Rewards with Toppers, 16 ct. (EU-610101)

Type of incentive: Pencil Rewards with Toppers
Color(s): red, white
Suggested grades: Pre-K-12
$15.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-JV58827
Model # EU610101
Carson-Dellosa Wild Style Stickers, Assorted Colors, 120/Pack (168136)

Carson-Dellosa Wild Style Stickers, Assorted Colors, 120/Pack (168136)

Incentives are designed as motivational stickers
Stickers feature positive words of encouragement and are available in different colors and shapes
The pack includes 120 stickers
$2.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-1560550
Model # 168136
Learning Resources Super Selves! Reward Capes, Blue/Red/Green/Yellow, 4/Pack (LER6371)

Learning Resources Super Selves! Reward Capes, Blue/Red/Green/Yellow, 4/Pack (LER6371)

Turn students into caring, sharing superheroes with the help of the reward capes
Blue, red, green, and yellow superhero capes each highlight a different aspect of social-emotional learning (SEL), including sharing, kindness, bravery, and caring
For children from three to six years
$37.99 Each
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-24477495
Model # LER6371
Carson Dellosa® Birthday Crown

Carson Dellosa® Birthday Crown

Age group and grade: Ages 4 - 11 years and grades preschool - 5th
Size: 23 1/2" x 4" sticker
Theme/design: Birthday
$23.29 Bundle
This item ships FREE *
Item # 901-931553
Model # CD-101021
Teacher Created Resources Under Construction Nailed It Awards, 30/Pack (TCR8140)

Teacher Created Resources Under Construction Nailed It Awards, 30/Pack (TCR8140)

Blank award cards to personalize
Recognize students for a job well done
Suggested age range: 4+ years
$7.29