close popup
Skip to main content
Skip to footer
More savings! More gifts! More choices!
Free Shipping on Orders $25+

Quill+

$34.99 paper price + exclusive monthly coupons + free shipping. Tell Me More

Close
Limited time offer

Free Shipping. No Minimum.

Code: FREESHIP

Offer good through 11/27/22.

Birthday Party Supplies  (44 Products)
Sort By:
  • Best Match
    • Best Match
    • Price:High-Low
    • Price:Low-High
    • Rating:High-Low
    • Rating:Low-High
  • Brand
    • Amscan (7)
    • Beistle (10)
    • Celebrations (3)
    • Creative Converting (12)
    • JAM Paper (5)
    • Touch of Color (7)
  • Price

    • $0 - $10 (12)
    • $10 - $20 (21)
    • $20 - $30 (10)
    • $30 - $40 (1)
  • Party Decor Type
    • Food & Beverage Accessories (16)
    • Kits (4)
    • Candles (2)
    • Bags (1)
  • Theme
    • Party (14)
    • Birthday (5)
    • Fourth of July (1)
    • Holiday (1)
  • More Ways to Shop
    • Best Sellers (18)
  • Product Ratings
    • and up (2)
    • and up (2)
    • and up (2)
Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5, Primary Assorted, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (170002.99)
Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5, Primary Assorted, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (170002.99)

Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5'', Primary Assorted, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (170002.99)

288 Total Pieces
Wax Birthday Candle
Multicolor Spiral Designs
$8.89 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1969762ACB
Model # 170002.99
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 2 3/8 x 1/4, Blue, Yellow & Red with Stripes, 24/Pack (5264560345
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 2 3/8 x 1/4, Blue, Yellow & Red with Stripes, 24/Pack (5264560345

JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 2 3/8 x 1/4, Blue, Yellow & Red with Stripes, 24/Pack (52645603454)

Made from high quality wax, has a smooth finish, and a colorful design!
Candle Size: 0.25 x 2.125 inches tall
Quantity: 24 candles (8 of each design)
$10.79 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-2478208
Model # 52645603454
Beistle Happy Birthday Party Kit, 11/Pack (55022)
Beistle Happy Birthday Party Kit, 11/Pack (55022)

Beistle Happy Birthday Party Kit, 11/Pack (55022)

5 (1)
Theme: Birthday
Used for festive occasions
High quality
$16.59 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1066892BEI
Model # 55022
Beistle 5 x 21 Happy Birthday Blank Sign Banner; 3/Pack
Beistle 5 x 21 Happy Birthday Blank Sign Banner; 3/Pack

Beistle 5' x 21" Happy Birthday Blank Sign Banner; 3/Pack

5 (1)
Package quantity: 3/pack
Theme: Birthday
Design: Happy Birthday
$18.59 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1011122BEI
Model # 50187
Amscan Birthday Balloons Tableware Kit, Rainbow (WL930157)
Amscan Birthday Balloons Tableware Kit, Rainbow (WL930157)

Amscan Birthday Balloons Tableware Kit, Rainbow (WL930157)

Get everything you need to throw a most colorful birthday celebration around with this birthday tableware kit for 18 guests
Items in the kit feature designs in rainbow colors
Kit contains 36 plates (7" and 9") with a Happy Bday message written out in balloons, 36 matching beverage napkins (5"), 36 Let's Party lunch napkins (6"), and a Happy Birthday banner ("10' x 12.5")
$20.99 Each
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-24504690
Model # WL930157
Beistle 15 Gleam N Burst Centerpiece; Multicolor, 3/Pack
Beistle 15 Gleam N Burst Centerpiece; Multicolor, 3/Pack

Beistle 15" Gleam 'N Burst Centerpiece; Multicolor, 3/Pack

15"
Package quantity: 3/pack
Theme: Birthday
$26.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1068010BEI
Model # 50809-MC
Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5, Assorted, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (17105.99)
Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5, Assorted, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (17105.99)

Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5", Assorted, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (17105.99)

288 Total Pieces
Wax Birthday Candle
Multicolor Spiral Designs
$11.59 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1969763ACB
Model # 17105.99
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 2 3/8 x 3/4, Black & White Polka Dots & Stripes, 24/Pack (5624560
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 2 3/8 x 3/4, Black & White Polka Dots & Stripes, 24/Pack (5624560

JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 2 3/8 x 3/4, Black & White Polka Dots & Stripes, 24/Pack (56245603624)

Made from high quality wax, has a smooth finish, and a sleek design!
Candle Size: 0.25 x 2.125 inches tall
Quantity: 24 candles (8 of each design)
$10.99 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-2478198
Model # 56245603624
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 4 x 1/4, Multi-Color Assortment, 12/Pack (52675607284)
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 4 x 1/4, Multi-Color Assortment, 12/Pack (52675607284)

JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 4 x 1/4, Multi-Color Assortment, 12/Pack (52675607284)

Made from high quality wax, has a smooth finish, and a fun patterned design!
Candle Size: 0.25 x 4 inches tall
Quantity: 12 candles (2 of each pattern)
$19.79 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-2478212
Model # 52675607284
Amscan Birthday Confetti Latex Balloons, 12, 3/Pack, Bright Assorted, 20 Per Pack (115503)
Amscan Birthday Confetti Latex Balloons, 12, 3/Pack, Bright Assorted, 20 Per Pack (115503)

Amscan Birthday Confetti Latex Balloons, 12'', 3/Pack, Bright Assorted, 20 Per Pack (115503)

60 Total Pieces
Latex balloon can be filled with air
Printed Design
$28.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1969929ACB
Model # 115503
Beistle Plush Birthday Cake Hat, 2/Pack
Beistle Plush Birthday Cake Hat, 2/Pack

Beistle Plush Birthday Cake Hat, 2/Pack

One size fits most
Package quantity: 2/pack
Theme: Birthday
$29.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1071477BEI
Model # 60717
Creative Converting Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCBDAY1P)
Creative Converting Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCBDAY1P)

Creative Converting Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCBDAY1P)

11 piece photo prop kit
Made of paper and plastic
Perfect addition to birthday parties
$17.59 Each
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-24301273
Model # DTCBDAY1P
Beistle Glittered Metal Birthday Princess Tiara; Silver
Beistle Glittered Metal Birthday Princess Tiara; Silver

Beistle Glittered Metal Birthday Princess Tiara; Silver

Theme: Birthday
Design: Birthday Princess
Includes 2 attachable combs
$12.59 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1071523BEI
Model # 60631
Beistle 35 Happy Birthday Streamer; 7/Pack
Beistle 35 Happy Birthday Streamer; 7/Pack

Beistle 35" Happy Birthday Streamer; 7/Pack

Package quantity: 7/pack
Theme: Birthday
Paperboard stock
$24.59 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1069642BEI
Model # 55400
Beistle Happy Birthday Confetti; Multicolor, 5/Pack
Beistle Happy Birthday Confetti; Multicolor, 5/Pack

Beistle Happy Birthday Confetti; Multicolor, 5/Pack

Theme: Birthday
Application: Table decoration
Design: Happy Birthday
$25.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1072861BEI
Model # CN022
Amscan Birthday Confetti Latex Balloons, 12, Bright Assorted Colors, 3/Pack, 20 Per Pack (115504)
Amscan Birthday Confetti Latex Balloons, 12, Bright Assorted Colors, 3/Pack, 20 Per Pack (115504)

Amscan Birthday Confetti Latex Balloons, 12", Bright Assorted Colors, 3/Pack, 20 Per Pack (115504)

60 Total Pieces
Latex balloon can be filled with air
Printed Design
$30.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1971168ACB
Model # 115504
Amscan Happy Birthday Confetti; 5oz, 2pk
Amscan Happy Birthday Confetti; 5oz, 2pk

Amscan Happy Birthday Confetti; 5oz, 2/Pack (369117)

Metallic confetti decoration
Multicolored
5 oz
$19.99 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1969937ACB
Model # 369117
Creative Converting Polka Dot Number 3 Candle (104562)
Creative Converting Polka Dot Number 3 Candle (104562)

Creative Converting Polka Dot Number 3 Candle (104562)

Polka dot birthday candle
Assorted color candle made of wax
Product dimensions: 1.5"W x 3"H
$5.49 Each
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1005582Q
Model # 104562
Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5, White, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (17105.08)
Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5, White, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (17105.08)

Amscan Spiral Birthday Candles, 2.5", White, 12/Pack, 24 Per Pack (17105.08)

288 Total Pieces
Wax Birthday Candle
Spiral White Design
$8.79 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1969764ACB
Model # 17105.08
Beistle Glittered Metal Happy Birthday Tiara; Silver
Beistle Glittered Metal Happy Birthday Tiara; Silver

Beistle Glittered Metal Happy Birthday Tiara; Silver

Theme: Birthday
Design: Happy Birthday
Includes 2 attachable combs
$12.59 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1071524BEI
Model # 60630
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 3 1/2 x 3/8, Bubble Style, Yellow, Fuchsia Pink, Blue, Green & Or
JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 3 1/2 x 3/8, Bubble Style, Yellow, Fuchsia Pink, Blue, Green & Or

JAM Paper® Birthday Candle Sticks, 3 1/2 x 3/8, Bubble Style, Yellow, Fuchsia Pink, Blue, Green & Orange, 10/Pack (52675607350)

Made from high quality wax and has a smooth finish!
Candle Size: 0.375 x 3.5 inches tall
Quantity: 10 candles (2 or each color) 5 colors: Yellow, Fuchsia, Blue, Green & Orange
$17.99 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-2478193
Model # 52675607350
Beistle Birthday Bash Confetti; Multicolor, 5/Pack
Beistle Birthday Bash Confetti; Multicolor, 5/Pack

Beistle Birthday Bash Confetti; Multicolor, 5/Pack

Package quantity: 5/pack
Theme: Birthday
Made of a Metallic plastic material
$27.99 Pack
This item ships FREE *
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-1072860BEI
Model # CN023
JAM Paper® Tall Birthday Candle Sticks, 5 x 1/4, Green, 12/Pack (52675606726)
JAM Paper® Tall Birthday Candle Sticks, 5 x 1/4, Green, 12/Pack (52675606726)

JAM Paper® Tall Birthday Candle Sticks, 5 x 1/4, Green, 12/Pack (52675606726)

Made from high quality wax, is tall and sturdy, and has a smooth finish!
Candle Size: 0.25 x 5 inches tall
Quantity: 12 candles per pack
$17.99 Pack
Qty Add to Cart
Item # 901-2478204
Model # 52675606726
Touch of Color Paper Dessert Plates, White, 75/Pack (753272B)
Out of Stock
Touch of Color Paper Dessert Plates, White, 75/Pack (753272B)

Touch of Color Paper Dessert Plates, White, 75/Pack (753272B)

Premium strength paper
Cake plates measure 7"
75 White Dessert Plates
$21.59 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008073
Model # 753272B
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting Confetti Sprinkles Birthday Napkins, 48 Count (DTC324664NAP)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting Confetti Sprinkles Birthday Napkins, 48 Count (DTC324664NAP)

Creative Converting Confetti Sprinkles Birthday Napkins, 48 Count (DTC324664NAP)

48 Confetti Sprinkles Birthday Napkins
Birthday napkins measure 6.5"
Birthday napkins are made of facial quality tissue
$17.79 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-2676923
Model # 324664
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Consider these Alternates
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Clear, 50/Pack (28114111B)
Out of Stock
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Clear, 50/Pack (28114111B)

Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Clear, 50/Pack (28114111B)

Premium Plastic
Cake plates measure 7"
50 Clear Premium Plastic Dessert Plates
$19.59 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008340
Model # 28114111B
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting 2 Ply Lunch Napkins, Black & Gold Birthday, 16/Pack (317546)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting 2 Ply Lunch Napkins, Black & Gold Birthday, 16/Pack (317546)

Creative Converting 2 Ply Lunch Napkins, Black & Gold Birthday, 16/Pack (317546)

16 Black & Gold Birthday Napkins
Luncheon napkins measure 6.5”
Made of facial quality tissue
$5.49 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-23973552
Model # 317546
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting Confetti Sprinkles Dessert Plates 8 pk (324662)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting Confetti Sprinkles Dessert Plates 8 pk (324662)

Creative Converting Confetti Sprinkles Dessert Plates 8 pk (324662)

8 Confetti Sprinkles Dessert Plates
Dessert plates measure 7”
Plates are made of paper
$17.59 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-23973631
Model # 324662
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Consider these Alternates
Creative Converting Boys Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCBBDAY1P)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting Boys Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCBBDAY1P)

Creative Converting Boys Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCBBDAY1P)

11 piece photo prop kit
Made of paper and plastic
Perfect addition to children’s birthday parties
$12.59 Each
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24301314
Model # DTCBBDAY1P
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Classic Red, 50/Pack (28103111B)
Out of Stock
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Classic Red, 50/Pack (28103111B)

Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Classic Red, 50/Pack (28103111B)

Made of plastic
Measures 7"
50 Classic Red Premium Plastic Dessert Plates
$9.49 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008371
Model # 28103111B
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, White, 50/Pack (28000011B)
Out of Stock
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, White, 50/Pack (28000011B)

Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, White, 50/Pack (28000011B)

Premium Plastic
Cake plates measure 7"
50 White Premium Plastic Dessert Plates
$18.99 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008320
Model # 28000011B
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting Girls Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCGBDAY1P)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting Girls Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCGBDAY1P)

Creative Converting Girls Birthday Party Photo Booth Kit (DTCGBDAY1P)

11 piece photo prop kit
Made of paper and plastic
Perfect addition to children’s birthday parties
$12.59 Each
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24301313
Model # DTCGBDAY1P
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Consider these Alternates
Beistle 3 3 Balloon Whirls; 15/Pack
Out of Stock
Beistle 3 3 Balloon Whirls; 15/Pack

Beistle 3' 3" Balloon Whirls; 15/Pack

Package quantity: 15/Pack
Theme: Birthday
Made of cardstock and metallic material
$22.99 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-1068655BEI
Model # 57633
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Consider these Alternates
Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Fresh Lime Green 8/Pack (533123)
Out of Stock
Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Fresh Lime Green 8/Pack (533123)

Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Fresh Lime Green 8/Pack (533123)

Premium strength paper
Cake plates measure 7"
8 Fresh Lime Green Dessert Plates
$6.99 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008205
Model # 533123
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting Happy Jungle 1st Birthday Napkins 16 pk (324580)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting Happy Jungle 1st Birthday Napkins 16 pk (324580)

Creative Converting Happy Jungle 1st Birthday Napkins 16 pk (324580)

16 Happy Jungle 1st Birthday Napkins
Luncheon napkins measure 6.5”
Napkins are made of facial quality tissue
$4.29 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-2677194
Model # 324580
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Bermuda Blue, 9/Pack (533552)
Out of Stock
Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Bermuda Blue, 9/Pack (533552)

Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Bermuda Blue, 9/Pack (533552)

Premium strength paper
Cake plates measure 7"
8 Bermuda Blue Dessert Plates
$1.89 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008024
Model # 533552
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, School Bus Yellow, 50/Pack (28102111B)
Out of Stock
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, School Bus Yellow, 50/Pack (28102111B)

Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, School Bus Yellow, 50/Pack (28102111B)

Premium Plastic
Cake plates measure 7"
50 School Bus Yellow Premium Plastic Dessert Plates
$15.59 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008370
Model # 28102111B
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting #1 Grad Dessert Plates, 54/Pack (DTC335380PLT)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting #1 Grad Dessert Plates, 54/Pack (DTC335380PLT)

Creative Converting #1 Grad Dessert Plates, 54/Pack (DTC335380PLT)

54 #1 Grad Dessert Plates
Disposable plates measure 7"
Made of premium paper allowing for easy clean-up
$26.99 Each
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24388606
Model # DTC335380PLT
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting #1 Grad Dessert Plates, 24/Pack (DTC335381PLT)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting #1 Grad Dessert Plates, 24/Pack (DTC335381PLT)

Creative Converting #1 Grad Dessert Plates, 24/Pack (DTC335381PLT)

24 #1 Grad Dessert Plates
Disposable plates measure 7"
Made of premium paper allowing for easy clean-up
$16.99 Each
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24388581
Model # DTC335381PLT
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Consider these Alternates
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Glittering Gold, 50/Pack (28103011B)
Out of Stock
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Glittering Gold, 50/Pack (28103011B)

Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Glittering Gold, 50/Pack (28103011B)

Made of plastic
Dessert plates measure 7"
50 Glittering Gold Premium Plastic Dessert Plates
$8.49 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008589
Model # 28103011B
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Black Velvet, 50/Pack (28134011B)
Out of Stock
Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Black Velvet, 50/Pack (28134011B)

Touch of Color Plastic Dessert Plates, Black Velvet, 50/Pack (28134011B)

Premium Plastic
Cake plates measure 7"
50 Black Velvet Premium Plastic Dessert Plates
$14.59 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008144
Model # 28134011B
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting Glamour Gray Dessert Plates, 24 Count (339645)
Out of Stock
Creative Converting Glamour Gray Dessert Plates, 24 Count (339645)

Creative Converting Glamour Gray Dessert Plates, 24 Count (339645)

24 paper plates
Paper plates measure 7"
Perfect for cake and desserts
$4.79 Each
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24387704
Model # 339645
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Creative Converting Polka Dot 1 Numeral Candle
Out of Stock
Creative Converting Polka Dot 1 Numeral Candle

Creative Converting Polka Dot 1 Numeral Candle

Color: White
Material: Wax
Pieces per package: 1
$5.49 Each
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-1005584
Model # 104560
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Cobalt Blue, 8/Pack (317375)
Out of Stock
Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Cobalt Blue, 8/Pack (317375)

Celebrations Paper Dessert Plates, Cobalt Blue, 8/Pack (317375)

Premium strength paper
Cake plates measure 7"
8 Cobalt Blue Dessert Plates
$1.99 Pack
Notify Me When In Stock
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
Item # 901-24008055
Model # 317375
Out of Stock
This item is currently unavailable.
SS,113278
NewsWeek website
loadingLoading...